Starters
-
Appetizer Combo
mozzarella marinara, meatball kabob, spinach dip
$14.79
-
Mozzarella Marinara
hand breaded mozzarella, marinara
$11.49
-
Calamari
hand breaded calamari, marinara
$12.99
-
Bruschetta
grilled baguette topped with bruschetta tomatoes, balsamic reduction, roasted garlic
$10.99
-
Meatball Kabob
three house meatballs, fresh mozzarella, roma tomatoes, basil, balsamic
$10.49
-
Spinach Dip
homemade recipe, served with grilled baguette
$10.99
-
Fried Banana Pepper Rings
banana pepper rings, lightly breaded, flash fried, and served with house made marinara
$8.99
-
Pepperoni Pinwheels
pepperoni and mozzarella cheese rolled up and baked in our house made pizza dough, marinara sauce
$10.99
-
Baked Goat Cheese
marinara, crumbled goat cheese, Italian seasoning, grilled baguette
$10.99
Flatbread
-
Mamma Mia Flatbread
grilled chicken, red onions, bruschetta tomatoes, green peppers, tomato cream sauce
$11.99
-
Bar-B-Q Chicken Flatbread
barbecue chicken, mushrooms, red onions, green peppers, barbecue sauce
$11.99
-
Dean Martin Italian Flatbread
crumbled sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, banana peppers, tomato cream sauce
$11.99
-
Pepperoni Flatbread
pepperoni, italian cheese blend, fresh basil
$11.99
Soup
-
Minestrone Soup
house recipe with beans, bacon, and indiana vegetables
Bowl $6.29
-
Italian Wedding Soup
homemade recipe with italian sausage, acini ce pepe pasta, spinach, carrots, and seasoned chicken broth
Bowl $6.29
-
Soup of the Day
Monday: Tomato Bisque
Tuesday: Potato
Wednesday: Tuscan Bean
Thursday: Potato
Friday: Clam Chowder
Saturday: Tuscan Bean
Sunday: Smoky Pablano & Cheese
Salad
-
Basil Pesto Tortellini
cheese tortellini basil, pesto, tomato, red onion, parmesan
$12.99
-
Spinach & Goat Cheese
baby spinach, shredded mozzarella, red onion, mushrooms, chopped bacon, sliced pepperoni, crumbled goat cheese, housemaid Italian dressing
$11.99
-
House Caesar
romaine, house caesar dressing, parmesan, croutons
$6.29
-
Tomato Caprese
indiana tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil
$10.49
-
All You Can Eat Salad, Soup, and Breadsticks
choose minestrone, italian wedding, or soup of the day
$10.49
Italian Pasta Classics
All Entrées Are Served with All You Can Eat Salad, Caesar Salad, or Soup Gluten-Free Spaghetti Available to Substitute on Any Dish for $1 Add Baked Cheese to any Pasta Dish for $2-
Tortellini Alfredo
parmesan cream sauce
$14.29
-
Spaghetti
marinara or meat sauce
$13.99
-
Spaghetti & Meatballs
marinara or meat sauce
$14.99
-
Lasagna Classico
crumbled meatballs and sausage, ricotta, meat sauce
$14.99
-
Fettuccine Alfredo
parmesan cream sauce
$14.79
-
Cheese Ravioli
marinara, meat sauce, or alfredo
$14.29
-
Portabella Mushroom Ravioli
marinara, meat sauce, or alfredo
$14.99
-
Baked Rigatoni
meat sauce, bell peppers, Italian sausage links, baked mozzarella
$16.99
Build Your Own Pasta
Create your own signature pasta dish. Includes all you can eat salad or soup and breadsticks.-
You Be The Chef!
$13.99
Pastas
Choose One-
Penne
-
Fettuccine
-
Linguine
-
Spaghetti
-
Whole Wheat Penne
-
Angel Hair
-
Rigatoni
-
Gluten-Free Spaghetti
+ $1
Sauces
Choose one-
Meat sauce
Bolognese
-
Alfredo
Parmesan Cream Sauce
-
Truffle Mushroom Cream
+$1
-
Marinara
Classic Red Sauce
-
Pesto
Basil, pine nuts & olive oil
-
Scampi
You Be The Chef
Choose up to three-
Bruschetta tomatoes
-
Sliced Black Olives
-
Capers
-
Zucchini
-
Green Peppers
-
Broccoli
-
Sliced Mushrooms
-
Pine Nuts
-
Sliced Red Onions
-
Peas
-
Spinach
-
Banana Peppers
-
Pepperoncinis
-
Red Peppers
-
Jalapeños
-
Zucchini
Top It Off
Choose any for an additional charge-
Grilled Chicken
$3
-
Grilled Shrimp
$4
-
Smoked Gouda
$2
-
Fra' Mani Capocollo
$3
-
Fra' Mani Pancetta
$3.50
-
Baked White Cheddar Blend
$2
-
Two Meatballs
$3
-
Salmon
$4
-
Fra' Mani Salame Rosa
$3
-
Italian Sausage
$3
-
Diced Ham
$3
-
Chopped Bacon
$3
-
Goat Cheese
$2
Chicken
All Entrées Are Served with All You Can Eat Salad, Caesar Salad, or Soup Gluten-Free Spaghetti Available to Substitute on Any Dish for $1-
Cajun chicken fettuccine
sautéed cajun chicken with fettuccine and alfredo sauce
$17.49
-
Chicken Marsala
chicken with mushrooms and marsala sauce. fettuccine alfredo or spaghetti marinara and steamed vegetables
$17.99
-
Chicken Alfredo
parmesan cream sauce
$17.49
-
Chicken Parmesan
chicken topped with italian cheese blend & marinara sauce, served with spaghetti marinara
$17.49
-
Chicken Scallopini
chicken over linguine pasta topped with capers and a lemon cream sauce
$17.99
Specialty Pasta
All Entrées Are Served with All You Can Eat Salad, Caesar Salad, or Soup Gluten-Free Spaghetti Available to Substitute on Any Dish of $1-
Fettuccine Tuscany
fra’mani capocollo, sautéed chicken, mushrooms with fettuccine alfredo
$17.99
-
Pasta á la carbonara
diced ham, peas, bacon, mushrooms with linguine and parmesan cream sauce
$17.99
-
Jambalaya Pasta
italian sausage, chicken, sautéed shrimp, bacon bits, red onions, green pepper, red pepper, bruschetta tomatoes, served over penne with marinara sauce
$17.99
-
Truffle Mushroom Chicken Pasta
fettuccini with chicken, mushrooms, and our house made mushroom truffle cream sauce. topped with shaved parmesan cheese and bacon
$18.99
-
Pasta Primavera
linguine pasta, house made marinara, bruschetta tomatoes, zucchini, red onions, mushrooms, bell peppers
$14.99
Seafood
All Entrées Are Served with All You Can Eat Salad, Caesar Salad, or Soup Gluten-Free Spaghetti Available to Substitute on Any Dish for $1-
Lemon Caper Salmon
8 oz. atlantic filet, olive oil, lemon, capers. served with fettuccine alfredo or spaghetti marinara and steamed vegetables
$18.99
-
Shrimp Alfredo
parmesan cream sauce
$18.99
-
Shrimp Scampi
shrimp sautéed in garlic and herbs tossed in a lemon wine butter sauce and bruschetta tomatoes served on top of linguine
$18.99
-
Garlic Butter Salmon
8oz Atlantic filet, angel hair pasta, scampi sauce, bruschetta tomatoes, steamed vegetables
$18.99
Sandwiches
10” Sandwiches Made with Our Artisan Baguette. Served with French Fries and Horseradish Pickles. Add All You Can Eat Salad or Soup for $3-
Italian Sub
fra’mani capocollo, fra’mani salame rosa, pepperoni, mozzarella, romaine, tomato, house italian dressing
$12.99
-
Meatball sub
house baked meatballs, marinara, italian cheese blend
$11.99
-
Hot Italian Roast Beef
roast beef, red peppers, green peppers, red onions, italian cheese blend, and au jus
$11.99
-
Michaelangelo’s Traditional Stromboli
crumbled italian sausage, italian cheese blend, green peppers, red peppers, red onion, and pizza sauce
$12.99
-
Veggie Stromboli
Italian cheese blend, green peppers, red peppers, red onion, and pizza sauce
$12.99
-
Chicken Parm Sandwich
breaded chicken tenderloins served on a toasted baguette topped with house made marinara and melted cheese blend
$12.99
Pizza
All Pizzas Include Our Homemade Ground-Tomato Sauce, Italian Cheese Blend and Are Served on Our Homemade Hand-Tossed Crust Add All You Can Eat Salad or Soup for $3-
Freestyle
Small (Served 1-2) $8.99
Medium (Served 3-4) $12.49
Large (Serves 3-5) $14.49
Cauliflower Gluten-Free Non GMO Pizza Crust Available
In Small Only Add $2
-
Add Veggies
All Local when available
Black Olives, Green Olives, Red Onions, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Bruschetta Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, SpinachSmall (Serves 1-2) $0.99
Medium (Served 3-4) $1.49
Large (Serves 3-5) $2.49
-
Add Meat
Bacon Bits, Italian Sausage, Smoking Goose Capocollo, Fra’mani Salame Rosa, Pepperoni, Ham, Chicken, American Sausage, Fra’mani Pancetta
Small (Serves 1-2) $0.99
Medium (Serves 3-4) $1.49
Large (Serves 3-5) $2.49
Specialty Pizzas
Small (serves 1-2): $12.99 | Medium (serves 3-4): $16.99 | Large (serves 3-5): $21.49-
Margherita
house made pizza sauce, indiana tomatoes, fresh basil, mozzarella
-
Bar-B-Q Chicken
grilled chicken, barbecue sauce, red onions, smoked gouda
-
Meatlover’s pizza
bacon, italian sausage, american sausage, pepperoni, ham, smoked gouda
-
Michaelangelo’s Deluxe
pepperoni, italian sausage, red onions, green peppers, mushrooms, italian cheese blend
-
Northern Italian
alfredo sauce, chicken, ricotta cheese, bacon bits, mushrooms, smoked gouda, italian cheese blend
-
Seasonal Pizza
Ask Your Server for Our Seasonal Pizza Option!
-
Individual Pan Pizzas
Michaelangelo’s Deluxe $7.99
Pepperoni $6.79
Cheese $5.79
Served Monday - Saturday 11 am - 4 pm
All Entree's Served with All You Can Eat Salad, Caesar Salad, or Soup Sub Gluten-Free Spaghetti on Any Entree for $1
Italian Pasta Classics
-
Tortellini Alfredo
parmesan cream sauce
$10.49
-
Spaghetti
marinara or meatsauce
$9.49
-
Spaghetti & Meatball
marinara or meatsauce
$10.49
-
Lasagna Classico
crumbled meatballs & sausage. ricotta, meat sauce
$10.49
-
Fettuccine Alfredo
parmesan cream sauce
$11.49
-
Cheese Ravioli
marinara, meatsauce, or alfredo
$10.49
-
Portabella Mushroom Ravioli
marinara, meatsauce, or alfredo
$10.49
Lunch Features
-
Lemon Caper Salmon
6oz atlantic fillet, lemon pepper spice, capers, vegetables
$11.49
-
Soup + Salad + Breadsticks
endless soup, salad, and breadsticks
$8.99
-
Pizza + Salad Combo
one topping individual pizza & endless salad bowl
$9.49
-
Half Sandwich Combo
choose your favorite half sandwich with choice of soup or endless salad bowl
$9.49
-
Half Flatbread & Salad
choose your favorite flatbread & endless salad bowl
$9.49
-
Dipping Sauce for Breadsticks Ramekin
marinara, alfredo, or nacho cheese
$0.99
boat $3.49
Daily Features
-
Monday
$10 pasta night
-
Tuesday
1/2 priced bottles of wine & sangria carafes
-
Wednesday
Kids Eat Free!
-
Thursday
$6 italian margaritas
Birra
Domestic & Import Bottles
-
Bud Light
$4
-
Blue Moon
$5
-
Coors Light
$4
-
Miller Lite
$4
-
Michelob Ultra
$4
-
Peroni
$6
-
Stella Artois
$6
-
Yuengling Lager
$4
Crafts Cans & Bottles
-
3 Floyds Alpha King
American Pale Ale (6.6%)
$6
-
3 Floyds Gumballhead
Wheat Ale (5.6%)
$6
-
Sun King Sunlight
Cream Ale (5.3%)
$6
-
Sun King Osiris
Pale Ale (5.6%)
$6
-
Sun King Wee Mac
Scottish Ale (5.3%)
$6
Sangria
-
Michaelangelo's Signature Sangria
Michaelangelo's signature wine mixed with natural juices and fresh sliced fruit. Choice of red or white.
Glass $7
Carafe $22
Cocktails
-
Italian Margarita
cazadores blanco tequila, luxardo triplum, disaronno amaretto, citrus
$9
-
Limoncello Mule
tito's vodka, tramonto limoncello, barritt’s ginger beer
$8
-
Spritz
choice of aperol or campari, topped off with prosecco and sparkling soda water
$7
-
Blood Orange Mimosa
sparkling italian prosecco, blood orange syrup, fresh orange juice
$7
-
Bloody Mary
tito's vodka, zing zang bloody mary mix, worcestershire, green olives, horseradish pickles
$8
-
Amaretto Sour
disaronno amaretto, woodford reserve bourbon, sweet & sour, luxardo cherry
$8
-
Old Fashioned
Woodford bourbon or knob creek rye Clancy's single barrel, simple syrup, aromatic bitters, luxardo cherry
$9
Spirits
-
Aperol
italy
$6
-
Bailey's Irish Cream
ireland
$7
-
Campari
italy
$7
-
Carpano Antica Sweet Vermouth
italy
$7
-
Carpano Dry Vermouth
italy
$7
-
Disaronno Amaretto
italy
$8
-
tito's vodka
austin, texas
$7
-
Bombay Sapphire Gin
england
$7
-
Cazadores Blanco Tequila
mexico
$7
-
Dewar's White Label Scotch
scotland
$8
-
Bulleit Bourbon
shelbyville, kentucky
$7
-
Crown Royal
canada
$8
-
Jack Daniels
lynchburg, tennessee
$8
-
Woodford Reserve Bourbon
versailles, kentucky
$10
-
Knob Creek Rye Clancy's Single Barrel
kentucky
$11
-
Tramonto Limoncello
italy
$8
Wine
Bianco (White)
-
Chamisal Stainless Chardonnay
California
Glass $11
Bottle $33
-
Maso Canali Pinot Grigio
Italy
Glass $11
Bottle $33
-
Caposaldo Moscato
Italy
Glass $10
Bottle $30
-
Matua Sauvignon Blanc
New Zealand
Glass $11
Bottle $33
-
La Marca Prosecco
Italy
Glass $10
-
La Marca Rose
Italy
Glass $10
Featured Bottle
-
Pieropan Soave Classico
Italian White Blend, Italy 2020
$30
Vino Rosso (Red Wine)
-
Castello Banfi Chianti Classico
Tuscany, Italy
Glass $12
Bottle $36
-
Sella Antica Italian Red Blend
Italy
Glass $10
Bottle $30
-
Storypoint Cabernet Sauvignon
California
Glass $10
Bottle $30
-
Mark West Pinot Noir
California
Glass $9
Bottle $28
-
Tenuta Sassoregale Sangiovese
Tuscany, Italy
Glass $11
Bottle $33
Featured Bottle
-
Allegrini Palazzo Della Torre
Italian Red Blend Veneto, Italy 2018
$36
-
New York Style Cheesecake
Topped with A Strawberry Puree, Whipped Cream
$6.49
-
Cannoli
Homemade Filling, Topped with Chocolate Chips
$5.49
-
Gelato
Choose from Mint Chocolate Chip, Spumoni, or Vanilla Bean
$5.49
-
Tiramisu
ESPRESSO-INFUSED SPONGE CAKE WITH CREAMY MASCARPONE CHEESE MOUSSE FILLING, DRIZZLED WITH CHOCOLATE SAUCE
$5.99
-
Carrot Cake
Two Layers of Cream Cheese Icing, White Chocolate Ganache, Graham Cracker Crumbs
$6.49
After Dinner Drinks
-
Fresh Brewed Coffee
Regular or Decaf
$3
-
Bailey's & Coffee
Baileys Irish cream, regular coffee, whipped cream
$7
-
Rishi Hot Tea
earl grey, English breakfast, matcha super green, turmeric ginger
$4
Meals
-
Spaghetti
$5.99
-
Lasagna
$5.99
-
Ravioli
$5.99
-
Fettuccine
$5.99
-
Cheese Tortellini
$6.99
-
Kid's Pizza
1 topping
$5.99
-
Chicken Fingers
$6.99
Desserts
-
Kid's Gelato Sundae
vanilla bean gelato, whipped cream, chocolate
$4.99
-
Kid's Gelato
vanilla bean, chocolate, seasonal flavor
$3.99
Drinks
-
Milk, Chocolate Milk and all Soft Drinks served in a Kid's Cup with a Lid
-
Triple XXX Root Beer
Locally made in Lafayette, Indiana
$3.50
-
Triple XXX Root Beer Float
$4.50
Daily Features
-
Monday
$10 Pasta Night
-
Tuesday
1/2 Priced Bottles of Wine
-
Wednesday
Kids Eat Free!
-
Thursday
$6 Italian Margaritas